Kayak (PIIXIDE 2.04.0)
This release, dated 06-29-98, offers support
fot the Intel FX, HX, VX, TX, LX, BX, EX, and GX chipsets. Updates
and changes in this release include:
Vectra (PIIXIDE 2.04.2a)
This release, dated 10-11-98, offers support
fot the Intel FX, HX, VX, TX, LX, BX, EX, and GX chipsets. Updates
and changes in this release include:
Driver performance differences on my system are so small that it is extremely unlikely that you would feel a difference between one driver and another. I have been seeing more of a performance difference in seemingly identical fresh installations of NT than I do with changes in drivers. This brings the choice down to compatability with each system's hardware. I have been fairly fortunate that my choice of components are DMA / UDMA friendly. I have not encountered any compatability problems with any of the NT drivers I have tested over the last few months.
Testing
Windows NT was freshly installed to a
FAT 16 formatted partition. Aside from the benchmark programs, the
only non-MS installed programs or drivers used were for the DCS sound card,
the Matrox G200 video card, Hayes modem, and the D-Link ethernet card.
All tests were performed 3 times and the results were averaged. Between
each test the partition was defragmented and the system was rebooted.
System
Celeron 300A o/c'd 4.5X103
Abit BH6
Hitachi PC100 SDRAM (64 MB)
Matrox Millennium G200 Video (8 MB SGRAM)
DCS S805 A3D Sound Card
Quantum Fireball SE 3.2
Quantum Fireball ST 3.2
Matshita CR-574 CD ROM
D-Link DE-528 Ethernet Card
Hayes 5675 56K v.90 / Flex Modem
Inwin A500 Case w/ cooling
modifications
WinNT 4 Workstation
Drivers
HP
KAYAK XW Series 04XX
HP
VECTRA VL 6/XXX Series 8
HP Drivers and NT SP3 and SP4
In an effort to get a better view of the
drivers, I decided to test them with Service Pack 3, as well as Service
Pack 4.
Windows NT4 SP3
Test | WinNT SP3
DMA Enabled |
WinNT SP3
Tyan 4021 |
WinNT SP3
HP Kayak (2.04.0) |
WinNT SP3
HP Vectra (2.04.02a) |
WinBench 99 | . | . | . | . |
CPUmark 32 | 955 | 956 | 946 | 952 |
FPU | 2440 | 2440 | 2440 | 2430 |
Business Disk 98 | 3180 | 3000 | 3160 | 3350 |
High-End Disk 98 | 8560 | 8320 | 8300 | 8090 |
CPU Utilization | 3.23% | 4.75% | 3.08% | 3.05% |
Avg Seek (ms) | 13.1 | 13.1 | 13.1 | 13.1 |
Transfer - Beginning | 11200 KB per sec | 11200 KB per sec | 11200 KB per sec | 11200 KB per sec |
Transfer - End | 10200 KB per sec | 10200 KB per sec | 10200 KB per sec | 10200 KB per sec |
WinNT Build | 1381 SP3 | 1381 SP3 | 1381 SP3 | 1381 SP4 |
. | . | . | . | . |
Threadmark 2.0 | 5.23 MB per sec @
5.51% Utilization |
5.26 MB per sec @
9.59% Utilization |
5.22 MB per sec @
5.99% Utilization |
5.22 MB per sec @
5.23% Utilization |
. | . | . | . | . |
HD Tach 2.52 | . | . | . | . |
Transfer Rates
Max - Min - Avg In KB per sec |
11069 - 6546 - 9552 | 11065 - 6546 - 9553 | 11071 - 6545 - 9557 | 11069 - 6549 - 9560 |
Avg Seek -
Burst Transfer Rate |
15.0 ms
29.2 MB per sec |
15.1 ms
26.2 MB per sec |
15.0 ms
29.0 MB per sec |
14.9 ms
29.0 MB per sec |
Timed File Transfer
The last test was to test the speed in
transferring files between the two hard drives in a real-world application.
For this test, I transferred a 105 MB copy of Win95 cabs and other assorted
files between two 1000 MB partitions. The folder was moved from drive
0 to drive 1 and back again. This process was repeated three times
for each configuration with the results being averaged.
Timed File Transfer - SP3
Driver used | Time to transfer | MB per second |
SP3 DMA | 32.5 seconds | 3.23 MB per second |
SP3 Tyan 4021 | 33 seconds | 3.18 MB per second |
SP3 HP Kayak | 32 seconds | 3.28 MB per second |
SP3 HP Vectra | 32 seconds | 3.28 MB per second |
Windows NT4 SP4
Test | WinNT SP4
DMA Enabled |
WinNT SP4
Tyan 4021 |
WinNT SP4
HP Kayak (2.04.0) |
WinNT SP4
HP Vectra (2.04.02a) |
WinBench 99 | . | . | . | . |
CPUmark 32 | 956 | 950 | 948 | 944 |
FPU | 2440 | 2440 | 2430 | 2440 |
Business Disk 98 | 2910 | 3000 | 2860 | 3030 |
High-End Disk 98 | 8390 | 8070 | 8400 | 8070 |
CPU Utilization | 1.98% | 3.77% | 2.07% | 2.07% |
Avg Seek (ms) | 13.1 | 13.0 | 13.1 | 13.1 |
Transfer - Beginning | 11200 KB per sec | 11200 KB per sec | 11200 KB per sec | 11200 KB per sec |
Transfer - End | 10200 KB per sec | 10200 KB per sec | 10200 KB per sec | 10200 KB per sec |
WinNT Build | 1381 SP4 | 1381 SP4 | 1381 SP4 | 1381 SP4 |
. | . | . | . | . |
Threadmark 2.0 | 5.27 MB per sec @
5.41% Utilization |
5.25 MB per sec @
9.89% Utilization |
5.21 MB per sec @
5.69% Utilization |
5.23 MB per sec @
5.13% Utilization |
. | . | . | . | . |
HD Tach 2.52 | . | . | . | . |
Transfer Rates
Max - Min - Avg In KB per sec |
11062 - 6548 - 9548 | 11054 - 6550 - 9515 | 11071 - 6546 - 9512 | 11069 - 6545 - 9484 |
Avg Seek -
Burst Transfer Rate |
15.0 ms
29.2 MB per sec |
15.1 ms
26.2 MB per sec |
15.0 ms
29.0 MB per sec |
14.9 ms
29.0 MB per sec |
Timed File Transfer - SP4
Driver used | Time to transfer | MB per second |
SP4 DMA | 32 seconds | 3.28 MB per second |
SP4 Tyan 4021 | 33 seconds | 3.18 MB per second |
SP4 HP Kayak | 31 seconds | 3.39 MB per second |
SP4 HP Vectra | 30.5 seconds | 3.44 MB per second |
HP Vectra 2.04.2a |
|
|
& Tyan 4021 |